New Year, new cookies, it’s all in the details.

Hurray! It’s one of my favorite times of year again – cookie decorating time! Sure, you can decorate cookies at any time of year (and I do), but there’s something special about decorating holiday cookies. Last year, my very first blog ever was about decorating cookies, so this blog is special in that I feel like I’ve come full circle. It’s been a great year, and I’ve loved every minute of it.

Looking back at that first blog recently in preparation for this blog, I can see many changes. First, the name of that first blog has changed. Back in 2008, PJ had written a post calling herself the “lazy” cookie baker, so I flipped the title and called my first post The Other Cookie Baker.

As we prepared for a cookie decorating blog this year, Janet, our designer, said, “You know, that title just doesn’t make sense any more.” She’s right. of course. If you happened to read the two posts in sequence it makes perfect sense, but here we are 12 months later. I can barely remember what I did this morning, let alone last year, so we’ve updated the title to Cookie Decorating for the Holidays.

Hmmm, what else has changed since last year? I gave up dying my hair, and cut most of it off. I traded in my clunker of a Jeep for a sporty new Matrix (thanks Mike S. at Toyota, you rock!). It’s the first brand-new car I’ve ever owned, and I am lovin’ the mileage. It makes me feel good to be greener, too.

Speaking of cars,  this year my daughter is old enough to get her learner’s permit. I have a bit of a hard time with this one, because I very clearly remember getting my own permit and it truly doesn’t seem to be that long ago. I sort of wish I still had the beat-up old Jeep for her to practice in. It was a tank of a car and made you feel safe. The day I backed into the porch, I broke the railing and post, but the Jeep was just fine. How exactly does one survive their children learning to drive? I have a feeling that blindfolds will play a major role in 2010.

I’ve met some great people this year, too. Paul in Ohio is a frequent Live Chat customer. We talk baking and dogs. Paul’s Toby is a Golden Retriever and my Toby is a Golden Lab cross. Not many chats here contain “woofs,” but Paul’s do.

Here at King Arthur Flour, I’ve gotten to know Paula, Molly, and Julie in customer service, and Irene on the Baker’s Hotline. Irene, she’s a pip. Who else out there owns socks with Grant Wood’s American Gothic on them, and gives out handmade patience awards to her co-workers? Yep, she’s a pip and they have all made my year the brighter for being in it.

I guess I’m starting to sound like the last newscast on New Year’s Eve, so let’s depart from looking back and start looking forward, into the cookie jar. This year, our cookie-decorating lessons are going to focus on really fine piping work, and how to get those delicate little details on your cookies. The secret is something you most likely have in your kitchen already, a King Arthur year-round favorite. Yes, it’s… parchment paper!

To begin, we’ll need some cookies.

8-cookies-plain.JPG

Our holiday favorites for decorator cookies are our Holiday Butter Cookies and Gingerbread Cookies. They hold the shape from the cutters and don’t puff too much, so details still show up.

We also need a big batch of Royal Icing for the piping. Here’s how to put the icing together.

1-meringue.JPG

Soak the meringue powder in cold water for a few minutes while you gather the rest of your ingredients. It isn’t a necessary step, but helps keep the mix lump-free.

2-whipped.JPG

Whip the meringue mixture until foamy and soft peaks have formed.

3-birds-beak.JPG

This stage is also known as the bird’s beak stage, and you can see why. The foam won’t hold up stiffly on a finger, but will fall to the side, forming a beak. (Yes, I made a few bird noises with my “finger puppet.” What a geek! )

4-adding-sugar.JPG

At this point, you’ll want to start adding your sugar. It’s a good idea to sift your sugar, to avoid lumps in the icing. This is especially important for fine piping work. Beat in the sugar 2 cups at a time on low speed.

5-soft-texture.JPG

The finished texture should be soft and smooth but not fluffy at this point.

6-finger.JPG

Back to our digital tester. The icing should flow off your finger or a spoon, and disappear back into the rest of the icing by the count of 10. The little drizzles should just seem to melt away back into the rest of the batch. If not, add a little more water. If the icing slides off your finger and appears too thin, add a bit more sugar.

14-cut-tip.JPG

Once your icing is at the right consistency, it’s time to pipe. For outlining and flooding the cookie, you’ll want a larger tip than for the fine detail work. I like to use a disposable plastic piping bag with the end cut off, no special tips. I finding cutting a bit of the seam off as well helps keep smudges to a minimum.

9-begin-outline.JPG

One key to piping a smooth outline is to hold the tip of the bag above the surface of the cookie and let the icing flow downward. You need to stay close enough so that the string of icing doesn’t break, but far enough away so that you don’t rub the surface of the cookie with the tip of the bag.

10-outline.JPG

Slow and steady as she goes.

11-finish-outline.JPG

To finish, drape the end of the icing string to meet up with the beginning, and stop squeezing. Allow the two ends to “melt” together.

12-wrong-way.JPG

Just thought you’d like to see what holding the tip too close to the surface would look like. There’s no room for the icing string to form, so you end up with smudges.

15-flooding.JPG

Flooding is the name given to covering a large area of the cookie with icing. To flood, pipe out a thick line of icing, and keeping the tip buried in the icing. Move in lines or small circles, filling in the area completely. The outline you piped earlier will keep the icing from spreading over the edges of the cookies.

16-poor-flooding.JPG

If the icing is at the correct consistency, it will self-level and you’ll have a smooth, even layer of icing over the whole cookie. If the icing gaps and doesn’t flow together like in this photo, add a touch more water. If it overflows the edges, or seems watery, add a touch more sugar.

Let the iced cookies set at room temperature for at least an hour, until the surface is quite dry to the touch.

17-whole-parchment.JPG

In order to make very fine lines for decorating, you’ll need to form your own piping cones from parchment paper. Begin with a long rectangle or square.

18-half-triangle.JPG

Cut in half to form a large triangle.

19-small-triangle.JPG

Cut in half again to form a small triangle.

20-begin-cone.JPG

With the long straight side facing out, and the point facing you, begin to roll the paper in on itself to form the cone. If you ever made paper party hats, it’s the same thing.

21-finish-roll.JPG

Pull the cone tight until the tip is a sharp point with no holes, no gaps. You’ll have three points meeting up by the top of the cone. These will be folded down into the cone to hold the shape. Some folks like to add a bit of tape or a staple to hold the top together. I typically don’t do this, but if it makes you feel more secure, go ahead.

23-fill-cone.JPG

These cones will be fairly small, so only use a few teaspoons to fill the cone just under half full.

24-fold-one.JPG

To avoid having the icing squirt out of the top of the bag, you’ll make a number of folds. First, fold in both sides to the center.

25-fold-2.JPG

Next, fold the top down to where the top of the icing is.

26-fold-3.JPG

Last, fold that fold in half again.

27-how-to-hold.JPG

Holding a bag for fine icing is different from holding a bag for larger piping. The entire bag is held in the hand, with the folds snugged up under the thumb, and the thumb controlling the flow. To use, snip off the smallest possible tip of the cone. If you look closely at the tip of this cone, you can see a tiny bead of icing, just perfect for fine work.

28-straight-lines.JPG

Practice piping straight lines first. Remember to hold the tip above the cookie and let the icing drape.

29-dots.JPG

Add tiny dots for detail. Keeping the tip buried in the icing helps the shape stay round. Stop squeezing before you lift the tip up, and your dots will be more rounded on top than pointy.

30-more-dots.JPG

It’s surprising how stripes and dots can combine to make intricate and detailed cookies without being overly complicated.

32-flooded-and-piped.JPG

Let’s try combining stripes and dots over a flooded cookie for a stunning white-on-white look. First, add large dots around the outer edge of the cookie. The two lines in the center are the beginning of a diamond.

33-begin-diamond.JPG

Add the next parallel lines to finish the diamond. This will be finished with a crosshatch design. Use these first lines as guides so that all of your other lines will be parallel.

34-crosshatch.JPG

I’m a big fan of symmetry. To ensure that the crosshatch is even, count the number of lines in each direction. Here there are six lines from top to bottom, so make six lines from left to right as well.

35-finished-crosshatch.JPG

You counted the lines, didn’t you? And right now you’re double counting, right? OK, I confess! There are six lines in one direction, and seven in the other. Good thing I’m not teaching math anymore, eh?

36-added-dots.JPG

Add tiny dots around the edge of the diamond. Begin with the four corners, then add even numbers of dots on each side.

37-added-details.JPG

Add a few more straight lines in the empty spaces at the top and bottom.

38-finished-orn.JPG

A final few dots and you have a unique white-on-white cookie using just a few basic shapes.

39-finished-cookies.JPG

So using a few sheets of parchment, some fun cookie shapes, stripes, dots, and your imagination, you can produce some special cookies for someone special this holiday season, and all year long. Happy baking – and decorating!

MaryJane Robbins
About

MaryJane Robbins grew up in Massachusetts and moved to Vermont 20 years ago. After teaching young children for 15 years, she changed careers and joined King Arthur Flour in 2005. MaryJane began working on King Arthur Flour's baker’s hotline in 2006, and the blog team ...

comments

  1. jkolpandrews

    Hi! I’m wondering if the frosted cookies can be frozen, or if that would cause the icing to break or melt or something. I’m also curious about the tip on the royal icing recipe that says you can dip the top of a cooled cookie into the icing and scrape off the excess with a spatula. I’m having trouble imagining how a flat cookie could A) be dipped in that manner–how do you hold it without getting goo all over your fingers and the whole cookie? and B) come out with a decent-looking iced surface. Can you add any more detail? Thank you!

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Unfortunately, freezing the cookies may cause some issues when they thaw, as the icing could “melt” in a sense as you mentioned from the condensation that may form as they come back to room temperature. Dipping is a tricky one, and you really just try and grip the edges of the cookie as tightly as you can with the ends of your fingers and then use the spatula to try and scrape most of the excess dripping frosting off before flipping the cookie right side up and setting it to dry. It certainly will give you a more rustic look than the piped and flooded version, but some people may prefer that look and it can also be a lot faster if you are in a pinch for time. If you have any further questions, please feel free to call our Baker’s Hotline at (855-371-2253). Happy baking! Jocelyn@KAF

  2. Kat

    Thanks for your helpful tips and this wonderful blog. I read through all the comments, hoping to see someone else who was having the same trouble as me. I just made Easter sugar cookies, some with the decorating technique here and some with piped details over the flooded royal icing surface. Over the years I have tried a few different royal icing recipes; this time I used the KAF boxed icing mix, thinking that would make a difference. I always seem to have trouble with most of the cookies taking FOREVER to set up, so then I can’t transport them. I let them sit out overnight and still only about 1/3 were dry enough to transport to a dinner party I was attending. Am I doing something wrong?
    Hi Kat – I am sorry this has been frustrating for you. If you would like an icing that will dry faster and be more transportable, a thicker consistency is best. We love this recipe called Royal Icing. Make a batch that is a little looser for flooding and then another that is thicker for making the outlines for corralling the flooding. MaryJane has several blogs on cookie decorating. Here is a Blog for you to check out. Enjoy! Elisabeth

    Reply
  3. akfriedner

    Thank you for this post! I’ve never tried to decorate cookies this way (I’ve only ever put sprinkles on them), so I have a few questions:

    1. I only have a hand-held mixer, will this do?
    2. Is the finished product stackable? As in, if I want to give a tin of cookies as a gift, can I put one cookie on top of another without them sticking together?
    3. Did you use white fondant for that ‘white-on-white’ cookie, or did you spread the icing first using the ‘flooding’ technique?
    Thanks again!
    Hi there,
    If your hand mixer is good and strong, you should be fine. You can stack the cookies, but if they have a lot of delicate details, you might want to go with a single layer to prevent breakage. For these particular cookies, I’ve used all royal icing, no fondant. Hope this helps!!! ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  4. Leigh C

    Hi there, I have been reading all of the above info on making icing and using the meringue powder and sugar. I will be using my icing for my dog treats and wanted to know if there is something other than sugar that I could substitute to mix withthe meringue. Thank you for your time and information. P.S. I use King Arthur wheat flour in my dog treat recipies.
    I’d say it’s time to check with your vet. Just print off a copy of the Royal Icing recipe and bring it in with you and see if he/she feels it would or would not work. Confectioners’ sugar is the base of Royal Icing and you can’t really make it without the sugar. Good Luck! ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  5. Mandy S

    I have to say these cookies are absolutely beautiful! Looking forward to trying these as soon as the snow falls in a few months 🙂 Just a quick question though…what sort of shape would you call the “ornament” cookie and is that available here at KAF? Also I see in the very first photo those pretty snowflake shapes and was wondering if I could purchase those here as well – the only snowflake one I have is pretty basic. Thanks so much!
    Those cookie cutters are seasonal items, so they’ll be out soon for the holidays! Many other great cookie cutters can be found here as well. Happy baking! ~Jessica@KAF

    Reply
  6. Kim

    I work with royal icing with gel colors quite a bit but I have noticed more “bleeding” lately. I had thought it was more common during humid weather, but now I don’t think that alone is the problem. Have you had this problem and/or do you have any suggestions? For instance, red scarves on white polar bears bleed sometimes (not always) and I do make sure the base icing is quite dry (sometimes 24 hours) before I decorate… I’m stumped. I use high quality gels and I don’t believe I am over saturating the color. Thanks MaryJane!
    Hi Kim,
    It’s hard to tell with out seeing it, but it may be too much color in the icing. It’s very common with red especially, and of course will show up more against the white background. While this is a much drier time of year, all the snowfall has made the air a bit more humid, especially on melting days, so that may be playing a role too. Last thing I can think of is if the icing is too thin, it may get under the original (now dry) layer and seep up, causing the bleeding.
    Hope this helps. ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  7. marisajimstewart

    I made the snowflakes this year and I used the royal icing recipe. I wish I would have found this blog earlier. I painted the cookies with a brush so I did not get the nice white on the cookie. Instead I had to try to do it twice because the icing was translucent. The blue was not quite what I had in mind. I now know what I need to do – but what if you do want to paint the small cookies – what icing would you recommend? Also, it would be nice if with each cookie cutter a colored picture of the iced cookie would be great. I have cookie cutters I bought in the past and I don’t know exactly what they are. I know they are Easter and Christmas but it would be nice to have a finished product to give me ideas.
    Here is a link to what you may be looking for. Be sure to adjust the liquid to suit your needs for painting: http://www.kingarthurflour.com/recipes/simple-cookie-glaze-recipe
    Best wishes! ART @KAF

    Reply

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *