Cool! Easy homemade ice cream

Fudge chocolate chip toffee crunch ice cream.

Strawberry-mango sorbet.

Ginger-peach frozen yogurt.

We all have an ice cream flavor of our dreams, don’t we?

The one that pops into our head while standing in line at the ice cream stand, scanning the 45 flavors and NOT finding Strawberry Chocolate Chip.

I still lament the disappearance of Friendly’s Chocolate Marshmallow. Sounds simple, but oh, the deep-dark chocolate ice cream… the thick swirl of sticky white marshmallow, just enough to soften the chocolate’s bitter edge…

These days, gelato is everyone’s new best friend. And yes, it’s awesome stuff: thick, rich without seeming heavy, and incredibly flavorful.

But if you can even find gelato in your local supermarket (to say nothing of fresh-scooped gelato), it’s liable to be prohibitively expensive.

You thought Ben & Jerry’s was premium? Try buying real gelato.

Which is why you might want to consider making homemade ice cream. Yup, right there in your own kitchen.

Homemade ice cream can be as simple as a spoon, bowl, and your refrigerator’s freezer compartment. Or as complicated (read: expensive) as a gelato machine costing upwards of $1,200.

Thankfully, there’s lots of ground in between those extremes. And here in the King Arthur test kitchen, we make our frozen treats with Cuisinart’s simple electric ice cream maker.

Sales pitch? You bet. But unlike many smoke-and-mirrors, “don’t read the fine print” ads you probably see on a daily basis, this one is absolutely true.

You can make fabulous homemade ice cream VERY easily with a simple $59.95 electric ice cream maker.

We’ve tested other brands, and other models; and we’ve found the Cuisinart offers the best balance between performance and price.

Sure, you can spend a LOT of money on a home ice cream maker; but the possible uptick in ice cream quality just isn’t worth the huge difference in price – at least to us cheapskate frugal northern New Englanders.

Also, when you make your own, you can control the ingredients. Julie, an ice-cream-loving member of our Web team, says, “We’ve recently gotten into making our own ice cream and discovered how easy it is and how much fun. The reason we started was after reading all the unpronounceable words in the ingredients on store-bought ice cream.”

Simple is beautiful.

How easy is it to make your own Mocha Madness ice cream?

Just watch.

First, stir together milk, cream, sugar, espresso powder, cocoa powder, and vanilla.

Pour into the ice cream maker’s canister. Put on the lid, and press the power button.

Go cool your heels for 25 minutes, while the machine does its work.

When the ice cream is soft-serve consistency, add chopped-up Oreos (I like the chocolate-filled ones). Turn off the machine, scoop the ice cream out of the bucket, and enjoy.

At this point it’ll be soft-serve consistency.

Like this frozen yogurt.

For harder ice cream, stick it in the freezer compartment of your fridge for 2 to 3 hours, until it’s the consistency you like.

BTW, here’s a good tip: Most homemade ice cream becomes rock-hard when stored in the freezer longer than 6 hours or so. To keep ice cream hard but not rock-hard, stir in 1 to 4 tablespoons liquor before placing in the freezer. Use vodka, brandy, or match a liqueur to your ice cream flavor: I’ve used Kahlua in the ice cream above.

So, what’s up with that? The alcohol in the liquor acts as anti-freeze, and the ice cream stays hard, but scoopably so.

So, that’s homemade ice cream. Easy, right?

If you need more proof, check out our various “cool” blogs, where you’ll see how to make not just ice cream, but frozen yogurt, sorbet, and even American-style gelato – no $1,200 machine needed! Happy scooping –

Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
Sorbet Two Ways
Tart Cherry Ice Cream
Strawberries and Balsamic à la Mode
Chocolate Decadence
Coconut Ice Cream
Pineapple-Coconut Gelato
Strawberry Sorbet
Mocha Madness
Blueberry Cream Pie Ice Cream

And, to top them all off:

A Pair of Sundae Sauces

PJ Hamel
About

PJ Hamel grew up in New England, graduated from Brown University, and was a Maine journalist before joining King Arthur Flour in 1990. PJ bakes and writes from her home on Cape Cod, where she enjoys beach-walking, her husband, two dogs, and really good food!

comments

  1. Molly Ware

    Is it possible to substitute lactose free milk in ice cream recipes. I haven’t found lactose free cream at the store. I miss ice cream!

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Hi Molly! Yes, you definitely can use lactose-free or non-dairy milk to make delicious ice cream. You might enjoy the results better if you use a milk that’s a bit richer and creamier, like coconut milk instead of a low-fat, lactose-free version of regular milk. If you want to learn more about (delicious) dairy-free cream possibilities, you can check out the full article on our blog here. Happy baking! Kye@KAF

  2. Nenegoose

    Instead of chopping Heath bars, I buy Heath English Toffee Bits. They can be found by the chocolate chips, and I use them during the last 5 minutes of churning time in Nutella icecream. Wonderful!

    Reply
  3. Momlet

    Second time in a week making the Mocha Madness, using coarsely chopped Heath bars; quoting 18-year old son: “as good as Ben and Jerry’s” !
    Looks like I need to buy more paper, my list is getting too long! The Heath addition sounds AMAZING! Thanks for sharing. ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  4. sfoor

    Do you have any recipes for sugar free ice cream or even suggestions for substituting splenda. Yes I appreciate the purist point of view, but many people just can not eat sugar……

    Sure – just substitute Splenda to taste, as the sugar really has very little to do with the ice cream’s texture. PJH

    Reply

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *