Vanilla Rice Pudding: The best there's ever bean

A few years ago, I wrote a blog about bread pudding and how until I had my first bowlful, I wanted nothing to do with it. For a long time, I felt the same way about rice pudding, Rice to me belonged in stir-fry, not in dessert. And then a wacky twist of fate brought my new love and I together.

This past spring I ended up having a surprise surgery that left it very difficult for me to swallow solid foods for awhile. While recuperating on the couch, I delved heavily into the world of soft, squishy foods provided by friends and family. My favorite way to start the day became chocolate pudding and mashed potatoes became a luncheon mainstay.

At one point for variety we bought some tapioca pudding, and that proved to be quite delish. But I still had never had rice pudding. Something in the back of my mind always prevented me from picking up a container, or breaking out the saucepan.

Fast forward to a few months ago when Baking Sheet editor Susan Reid and I were chatting in the test kitchen. She was extolling the virtues of a good dish of warm rice pudding for curing the blues. I confessed to never having tried it, and vowed to give it a go. Ah Fate, you finally played a card on my side of the table. Simply put, rice pudding is da bomb.

I tried out a few different versions, and while all were quite yummy, I really like the plain vanilla versions best. I also like cooking the rice right in the cream/milk instead of using pre-cooked rice.

The thing that I think really makes this particular rice pudding recipe special is the vanilla itself. Our King Arthur Flour exclusive blend has a truly perfect combination of Madagascar and Tahitian vanillas. Pure, rich, and intensely vanilla, it is the only one I use now both at home and in the test kitchen.

Join me, and we’ll make this outstanding Vanilla Rice Pudding.

Place the milk, 3/4 cup cream, sugar, rice, and King Arthur Pure Vanilla Extract in a medium-sized saucepan over medium heat.

Yes, the rice is raw at this point. This particular rice pudding is cooked more like a risotto; the rice absorbing the cream and sugar during the cooking process.

Continue to cook over medium heat as the mixture simmers and bubbles gently. No boiling! This would cause the cream to curdle.

The rice will start to absorb the liquid. It will grow and become more transparent, while the liquid will begin to thicken from the rice starch.

Bubble, bubble, bubble, stir, stir, stir. Around the 30 minute mark, you’ll want to begin tasting the rice to see if it is done yet. You want a firm grain, not soggy and mushy, but also no crunch.

When the rice seems nearly done, add the remaining 1/4 cup of cream and the Vanilla Bean Paste. Adding more vanilla late in the cooking time will keep it from cooking out too much, giving you the best vanilla flavor, plus the flecks of actual vanilla bean.

There! Lovely transparent grains of rice and a creamy sauce of vanilla. Right now, I can’t think of anything more soothing and lovely, except maybe a beautiful mermaid stroking your hair as she sings you off to sleep.

The pudding can be served warm or cold. I like to have a little dish while it is still warm, and then chill the rest to enjoy like ice cream. I can’t begin to tell you how fragrant this little dish of pudding is. The vanilla is at once exotic and familiar, enticing and comforting. I think I’ll grab my spoon and dig right in to the best of both worlds.

Please make, rate and review our recipe for Vanilla Rice Pudding

Print just the recipe

Treat yourself to a bottle of amazing vanilla.

MaryJane Robbins
About

MaryJane Robbins grew up in Massachusetts and moved to Vermont 20 years ago. After teaching young children for 15 years, she changed careers and joined King Arthur Flour in 2005. MaryJane began working on King Arthur Flour's baker’s hotline in 2006, and the blog team ...

comments

  1. Lani

    Have you used Wild Rice? Saw an old Native American Recipe for Wild Rice Pie. It’s Just Cooked Wild Rice, Maple Syrup, and Eggs, in a Pie Crust. I have made this without a crust. Nice and nutty. Next time I do this, I am going to add the maple syrup to Wild Rice as it cooks. Maybe sprinkle some Maple Sugar on top. Tried this with left over Chinese Fried Rice. I used up some left over Mini Tart cups. IT was GREAT. I wonder how this would work with Pine Nuts??? Has anyone Ever Made a Pine Nut Pudding?

    Lani, we’ve been using wild rice in the fall breads we’ve been testing and baking for publication, but you make a good point, wild rice would be mighty tasty. Pine nuts tend to get soggy when cooked in liquids; that’s something we haven’t tried in pudding… Susan

    Reply
  2. annabekah

    Just had to share….because I am dieting, and because I was desperately craving this rice pudding, I decided to try it with skim milk and half and half. Plus, I never have arborio on hand, so I used regular long-grain white rice. It truly is an acceptable “lighter” recipe, prepared this way!! Still amazingly creamy and VERY vanilla-y!

    Thanks for the feedback – always good to know that these low-fat substitutions, which we all need to make sometimes, work well here… PJH

    Reply
  3. patriciaannk

    It looks like this is a gluten-free recipe. I’m hoping recipes will be added to the gluten-free recipe category.

    This can certainly be gluten free as long as ALL the ingredients are gluten-free. Our KAF Pure Vanilla and Vanilla Bean Crush are not a gluten-free items, so we cannot consider it completely free of gluten. Kim@KAF

    Reply
  4. creary1898

    I love rice pudding and have tried many recipes from Greek, Italian-all sorts! This one appealed to me because it is very similar to my favorite-only this one is much richer and very tasty,
    the vanilla is the key. Also, there are no RAISINS or any type fruit! Nell

    Reply
  5. PastorK

    I tried this last night, the flavor was good, but it came out super thick. It was almost one solid clump. I thought maybe the rice was cooked too long, but it still had a tooth to it and it was still good. Any ideas?
    I think it may have been over-cooked and too much of the liquid evaporated.

    Reply
  6. MariaNita

    sure MJ, here’s the recipe:
    1 cup fresh corn kernels (about 3-4 ears of fresh corn, don’t forget to scrape the cob with a spoon to get the corn “milk”)
    1 cup glutinous rice
    1 can coconut milk (about 2 cups)
    3 cups water
    3/4 to 1 cup sugar
    Combine all the ingredients in a large pot and bring to a boil, lower the heat, stir occasionally to prevent the rice from sticking and let it simmer until the rice is cooked.
    Thanks for sharing! Elisabeth

    Reply
  7. MariaNita

    here in the Philippines, we use coconut cream/milk and glutinous rice in cooking rice pudding but use freshly shredded sweet corn instead of raisins. smells heavenly.
    Wow, that is really interesting. Would you share a recipe here? I’d love to give it a try and I think I have everything in my pantry. ~ MaryJane

    Reply

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *