Active dry yeast: do you really need to dissolve it first?

Is it really necessary to dissolve active dry yeast before using it in bread? Inquiring bread bakers want to know!

You may have heard over the past year or so that active dry yeast (ADY) has been reformulated into a smaller particle size, and can now be used without dissolving it first – as had always been the requirement.

Note: Dissolving yeast and proofing yeast are two distinct processes. First we’ll cover dissolving; see the end of this post for information on when to proof yeast.

Really – you don’t need to dissolve ADY in lukewarm water before using it?

Let’s put it to the test.

DDissolving Yeast-2

On the left, dough made with undissolved ADY – yeast simply added along with the other dry ingredients. On the right, dough made with dissolved yeast.

Dissolving active dry yeast via @kingarthurflour

An hour later, the dough has risen. I don’t see any difference – do you?

Let’s shape some dinner rolls.

Dissolving active dry yeast via @kingarthurflour

I decided to bake the rolls all in one pan, to make sure neither pan nor placement in the oven would affect their rise. Top row are the rolls using dissolved yeast; bottom row, undissolved. (If you’re really tracking this, the roll at the left in the middle row uses dissolved yeast; middle roll at right, undissolved.)

The rolls rise for an hour. I still don’t see any difference.

Dissolving active dry yeast via @kingarthurflour

Nor is there any difference once they’re baked.

So, inquiring bakers – inquire no more! You don’t need to dissolve active dry yeast in lukewarm water before using it. (Even though it still says you should dissolve it on the back of the yeast packet, if you buy your yeast in packets.)

Now, what about that “proofing” stuff?

Proofing yeast – or as it used to be called, “proving” yeast – serves as proof that your yeast is alive and active. And how, exactly, do you do this?

Well, if you’re using a typical 1/4-ounce packet of yeast, just follow the directions on the back: dissolve the contents of the packet in 1/4 cup warm water with 1 teaspoon sugar. After 10 minutes, the mixture should be bubbly. Once you’ve proved the yeast is alive, go ahead and add it to your recipe – reducing the water in the recipe by 1/4 cup.

I actually never proof yeast. I use SAF instant, purchased from our Web site; I know it’s always fresh and vigorous.

But I did put a packet of Fleischmann’s to the test.

Dissolving active dry yeast via @kingarthurflour

Yeast dissolved in warm water with sugar on the left; same yeast, 20 minutes later. It only had a few small bubbles after 10 minutes, but 20 minutes did the trick.

Were you expecting foamy? Nah. But it’s definitely puffy.

And that’s proof enough the yeast is alive.

So, bottom line: dissolve yeast in warm water with a bit of sugar to prove that it’s alive. This shouldn’t really be necessary if the yeast isn’t close to its expiration date; and if you purchased it from a store with decent turnover. However, if you have any doubts about your yeast being good, go ahead and proof it.

But dissolve active dry yeast before using it – just because? No need. Add ADY to the bowl right along with the rest of the dry ingredients; your bread will rise just fine.

P.S. My fellow blogger, MaryJane, said I should let you know that if you want to dissolve your active dry yeast before using it, go right ahead. She’s right: no problem with dissolving it, if that’s the way you’ve always done it and want to continue.

PJ Hamel
About

PJ Hamel grew up in New England, graduated from Brown University, and was a Maine journalist before joining King Arthur Flour in 1990. PJ bakes and writes from her home on Cape Cod, where she enjoys beach-walking, her husband, two dogs, and really good food!

comments

  1. Jane Yazzie

    I used the “add yeast to the dry ingredients” direction; which caused the dough to be grainy. I suspect it’s from the yeast itself. This usually doesn’t happen when I poof the yeast first. Explain please….

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      We haven’t experienced this, Jane, so it’s possible that the yeast you prefer to use is a bit more granular than the ones we work with in our test kitchen, either SAF or Red Star. Feel free to proof your yeast in water if it gives you the results you prefer. Annabelle@KAF

  2. patrick houston

    bought yeast to make pizza. put required amount into warm water plus sugar, after 40 minutes , still no reaction! yeast said for bread, should this not work?

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Hi Patrick! There are two possibilities here. Since the yeast never bubbled, either it’s simply past its prime or the water was too hot and it killed it immediately. Yeast dies at 120°Fso it’s a good idea to keep the water temperature close to your body temperature. Annabelle@KAF

  3. Frances Mattre

    I made hot cross buns according to your recipe (to the tee). They came out more like a biscuit than a sweet dough bun. The dough was stiffer than when I make bread. If I would have added more milk would the texture change?
    They were very good however. I used KA all purpose as instructed. I wanted to use the bread flour but I was precise staying with the instructions. What could I have done wrong? I used organic eggs – perhaps they were smaller than a large. Should it be based on weight instead of by each egg?

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Frances, feel free to use a bit more milk for a softer dough! We’ve also had amazing luck making soft hot cross buns using the tangzhong method, as outlined in this blog post: Introduction to tangzhong. They turn out squishy and beautiful, and last longer as well. Happy baking! Kat@KAF

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *