Baker’s percentage: scaling recipes up and down the accurate (and easy) way

You know how sometimes you’re baking, and all of a sudden you feel the urge to say some very bad words?

Like when the pumpkin filling slops onto the floor as you juggle the pie on its way to the oven.

Or you set the timer for just 2 more minutes, to give those brownies a crisp edge – then go outside to get the mail, run into a neighbor, get chatting and, well… bad words are definitely said as the acrid smell of burned brownies fills the kitchen.

I have a pie crust recipe I’ve loved for years, but it’s always been just a tad… too… small for my favorite pie pan. Many’s the time I’ve said [bad words] while trying to roll the crust just a tiny bit larger – causing it, of course, to stick, tear, or both.

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

Some people like making delicate, thin pie crust; I prefer a more substantial crust, one that’s A) easier to work with, and B) doesn’t simply become inconsequential under its load of bubbling berries.

And this crust recipe – well, I could barely roll it wide enough for my 9″ wide, 1 1/2″-deep pie pan

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

…let alone make any kind of stand-up crimped edge. I mean, if you’re going to make a crimped edge, MAKE one.

Then one day (as my 5th grade teacher Miss Kellam would have said), “Light dawns on Marblehead!”

Why not make the crust a bit bigger?

I don’t need a new recipe; I love the crust. I just want more of it – not “double” more, just a little bit more.

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

The challenge: increase the size of the crust without changing the balance among its ingredients. I like the mix of butter and shortening, the “just enough” ice water that yields delicacy rather than cardboard-y hardness.

The solution: baker’s percentage, a.k.a. baker’s weights (or baker’s math).

Percentages? Math? What does this have to do with flour and butter and a wonderfully flaky pie crust?

Lots, as you’ll soon see.

Now, don’t click out of here; I’m not going all math-y on you. This is simple, once you get the hang of it. And pretty soon you’ll be making 17 muffins instead of 12, five biscuits instead of 15 – using just a couple of basic calculations.

Let’s take a look at a typical pie crust recipe and see how this works.

 

iphone-mockup

This is the beginning of our Classic Single Pie Crust recipe. You’ll notice I’m looking at the recipe not in volume, but in grams; baker’s percentage is all based on weight, not volume, so you’ll need a scale to try this at home.

And why grams? Grams are MUCH easier to calculate percentages with than ounces and fractions of ounces.

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

1. Start with the weight of the recipe’s flour.

Flour is pegged at 100%, and everything else is viewed as a percentage of flour. In our pie crust recipe, flour weighs 177g.

2. Compare the weights of the other ingredients to flour.

To determine the percentage of the other ingredients, divide each one by the weight of the flour (177g), then multiply the result (which is in decimal form) by 100 to convert it to a percent:

• The shortening (46g) is 26% of the flour, by weight: (46 ÷ 177) x 100 = 26%
• The butter (71g) is 40% of the flour, by weight: (71÷ 177) x 100 = 40%
• The water (using the lesser amount, 43g) is 24% of the flour, by weight: (43 ÷ 177) x 100 = 24%

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

3. Scale the recipe up (or down).

The original recipe calls for 1 1/2 cups of our unbleached all-purpose flour. Let’s say I want to increase that amount to 1 2/3 cups flour; I think that little bit extra flour is just the cushion I need to make the size crust I want.

The weight of 1 2/3 cups of flour is 201g (as calculated from our online ingredient weight chart, a super resource when you’re measuring by weight). Let’s see what the increased weights of the rest of our ingredients will be:

  • Shortening (26% of flour weight) = 52g.
  • Butter (40% of flour weight) = 80g.
  • Water (24% of flour weight) = 48g.

Now, that’s not so hard, is it?

But what about the salt, you say? Since it’s such a small percentage of the flour weight, I tend to salt to taste; I’d increase the salt by maybe 1/8 teaspoon, or a big pinch.

And what happens when a recipe you’re making includes eggs – which aren’t measured by volume at all, but by units? Well, a large egg weighs about 50g out of its shell – so take it from there.

Once you stop thinking in units or volume, and start thinking (and measuring) in grams, scaling recipes up and down becomes quite simple.

Baker's percentage via @kingarthurflour

And the results quite sublime!

Note: For a more detailed explanation, check out baker’s percentage on our professional site.

PJ Hamel
About

PJ Hamel grew up in New England, graduated from Brown University, and was a Maine journalist before joining King Arthur Flour in 1990. PJ bakes and writes from her home on Cape Cod, where she enjoys beach-walking, her husband, two dogs, and really good food!

comments

  1. Aldebaran Aldana

    Wow, what an useful tip, this is much more easy than trying to measure that 1 1/6 C or scaling each ingredient individualy. Thank you very much, you guys just saved my sanity.

    Reply
  2. Janice Coby

    What about extract? Do you convert tsp/Tbsp to grams, then figure the percentage it is to flour? Is measuring extract considered volume? Want to purchase a concentrated extract but need to figure the math to see if cost effective.

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Hi Janice. Since it’s usually measured in such small amounts, we measure extracts by volume in measuring spoons. You don’t need to include it with the liquid in a recipe unless you’re using over 1/4 cup of extract, which would be in a very large bakery-sized batch. Annabelle@KAF

  3. Lynda Moren

    Hmm. I’m not sure how that is easier than just increasing volume of water, butter and flour by 25%, and add a pinch of salt, for example, to make a bigger pie crust.

    Reply
  4. Peter L.

    I see the how to use bakers percentage, but how do you go about converting a recipe with different types of flours. I want to increase your Seeded Rye Sandwich Bread recipe to make a larger loaf (2 pound loaf in the Zoe). It consists of KAF AP flour, white rye flour and pumpernickel. Would I use the AP=100% and treat the other flours like any other ingredients?

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Peter, that’s a great question! You would treat all your flours together as 100% and just treat the seeds as extra ingredients, then figure out what ratios you wanted your individual flours to be in separately. Happy baking! Kat@KAF

  5. Greg Reese

    Very interesting article! But I’m curious, why would you use the ingredient weight chart if you’re already weighing the ingredients? I don’t understand the correlation between the two.

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Hi Greg! The chart is useful for those trying to convert a volume recipe to weights. These would be non-King Arthur Flour recipes since all of ours can be viewed by weight. Annabelle@KAF

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *