Your favorite sandwich bread recipe calls for potato flour. You open the cupboard, and GRRRRR: you used it up on those yeast rolls and forgot to restock. What now? Don’t give up on that bread! We’ve got several other ingredients you can substitute for potato flour while you work on restocking your supply.
Potato flour vs. potato starch
First, let’s clear up any confusion about potato flour and potato starch. Potato flour is made from whole peeled potatoes, cooked, dried, and ground into a fine, beige-colored powder. Potato starch is “washed” out of crushed potatoes, then dried to a fine, bright-white powder.
What’s the difference? Potato flour includes fiber, protein, and flavor, while potato starch is pure flavorless starch.
Starch helps keep bread and rolls soft, moist, and fresh by absorbing and holding liquid. When bread goes stale it’s because its liquid is evaporating; starch slows this process.
So while you wouldn’t want to use starch in a crusty baguette, it’s perfect for soft dinner rolls and sandwich loaves. Many King Arthur Flour yeast bread recipes call for potato flour, which adds not just starch, but a bit of creamy color and a faint hint of earthy, “potato-y” flavor.
But back to the problem at hand: you’re out of potato flour, and you really, really want to make your favorite sandwich bread. Oh, and you also don’t have any instant potato flakes, which function very similarly to potato flour in yeast bread, and can be used interchangeably (measured by weight).
Let’s do some tests using commonly available substitutes. I’ll make four loaves of White Sandwich Bread: one with potato flour as written; one that substitutes cornstarch for the potato flour; one that substitutes cooked, mashed potatoes, and one that substitutes all-purpose flour.Looking for the best substitute for potato flour? We've done the tests, and have some advice. Click To Tweet
Cornstarch is a worthy substitute for potato flour if you’re in a pinch. However, while it keeps bread and rolls moist, that’s the end of it. Cornstarch lacks the subtle flavor and color present in potato flour, and thus bread made with cornstarch tastes a bit flat and is slightly paler in color than bread made with potato flour.
Can I substitute cornstarch for potato flour? Yes, with reservations; your bread will be paler and less flavorful.
How to do it: Substitute cornstarch 1:1, by volume, for potato flour in yeast recipes.
Mashed potatoes add wonderful flavor and over-the-top moistness to yeast bread and rolls; witness one of my favorite soft roll recipes, Amish Dinner Rolls.
But the proper balance of liquid and flour is key to bread’s structure, and mashed potatoes are a wild card. If you bake the potatoes, how dry did they become? If you boil them, how much water did they absorb?
Substituting mashed potatoes for potato flour is possible, but dicey. See how rough the mashed potato dough is compared to the dough made with potato flour?
The mashed potato dough is sticky to work with. And though the resulting loaf’s internal temperature is the requisite 190°F when I remove it from the oven, it collapses as it cools. Better luck next time, I guess.
Can I substitute mashed potatoes for potato flour? Yes, with caution; your bread may collapse.
How to do it: Substitute 3/4 cup unseasoned mashed potatoes for every 1/4 cup potato flour called for in your recipe. Reduce any added liquid in the recipe by 50%, subsequently adding more flour or liquid if necessary to make a soft but not overly sticky dough. Bake the loaf thoroughly, to an internal temperature of at least 200°F.
Even after all this, a loaf made with mashed potatoes may collapse. I suggest using this substitution in rolls, rather than bread; a small roll’s structure is inherently more stable than that of a high-rising loaf.
If you choose to forego the benefits of starch entirely, you can simply substitute all-purpose flour for the potato flour in your recipe.
You’ll need to make some adjustments; potato flour absorbs more liquid than all-purpose flour. If your recipe calls for a range of water, start at the lower end. If the dough is still too sticky to handle easily, sprinkle in a bit more all-purpose flour.
Can I substitute all-purpose flour for potato flour? Yes, with regret; your bread will lack moistness, keeping quality, and a bit of added flavor and color.
How to do it: Substitute all-purpose flour 1:1, by volume, for potato flour in yeast recipes. The dough may be a bit stickier and harder to handle at first, but thorough kneading should create a smooth ball of dough. The resulting loaf will rise and bake well, but in comparison to a loaf made with potato flour will lack a bit of flavor and color. Its texture will be drier, and it’ll become stale more quickly.
So, at the end of the day, here’s my advice: If you don’t have potato flour, purchase some and make it a pantry staple. These tips are handy if you unexpectedly run out, but nothing beats the attributes (and ease of use) of potato flour.
Some final tips:
• Want to add potato flour to a yeast bread recipe that doesn’t call for it? Substitute potato flour 1:1 by volume, for the all-purpose, whole wheat, or bread flour called for in the recipe. We don’t advise substituting more than 1/4 cup potato flour in a typical bread or roll recipe calling for about 3 cups of flour. If you substitute potato flour for bread flour, you may notice your bread rises slightly less high.
• What about using potato water? Potato water — water you’ve boiled potatoes in — is rich in starch. Use it in soft bread or roll recipes in place of your usual tap water.
And finally, what if you’re out of potato flour, but have some potato starch on hand? My fellow blogger Kye answers that question all the time while responding to readers with recipe questions; here’s what she says:
“They’re not interchangeable when baking gluten-free; but they’re roughly interchangeable when being used to retain moisture in yeast breads. To be ultra-precise about it, potato flour is about 83% starch, so you’d perhaps want to substitute a little less potato starch; but realistically this kind of small adjustment is unlikely to make much of a difference.” As with cornstarch, potato starch doesn’t have the flavor or warm color offered by potato flour.