Regional desserts: a tour of America's local treasures


Join us on a tour of some of the regional dessert standouts we profiled in the Holiday 2017 issue of Sift magazine.

Every corner of our country has its own food history, including the quirky world of regional desserts. Thanks to the diverse cultures that have arrived on our shores, there are all kinds of local treasures from which to choose. As regions were settled, Old World bakers tried new ideas and ingredients. At times, their labors created something entirely new (and sometimes unexpected) that captured the hearts and stomachs of their neighbors.

Our rich tapestry of regional desserts is part of the joy of American travel. If you want to get to know a new place, get to know what the people point to with pride at their local bakeries.

Take a tour of America's quirky, delicious regional dessert specialties with Sift magazine. Click To Tweet

First of all, we’ll go to Charm City, a.k.a. Baltimore.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour

Berger Cookies

In 1835, a man named Henry Berger moved to Maryland from his native Germany. He opened a bakery in East Baltimore, and among the recipes he brought with him were these cookies. Known and loved for the thick layer of chocolate fudge frosting they wear, many Charm City natives keep a stash in the freezer to snack on in summertime. They’ve been a favorite of Baltimore natives for almost two centuries.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour

Benne Wafers

Sesame has long been a symbol of good luck in Africa. The word “benne” is the Bantu word for sesame, and these cookies have been ubiquitous in the South Carolina low country since Colonial times. These crisp, sweet cookies are a New Year’s tradition because they’re thought to bring good fortune in the year ahead.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour

Classic Key Lime Pie

Key limes arrived in Florida with the Spanish settlers, traveling from what’s now known as Haiti. The trees flourished there in the early 1900s, replacing commercially grown pineapples. The smaller, lighter colored limes were prized for their flavor, which is sweeter than Persian limes. At around the same time, Gail Borden invented sweetened condensed milk. It was brought to Florida soon after by a ship’s chandler named William Curry. It wasn’t long before those two ingredients were introduced to one another, and the smooth, sweet-tart pie became a local specialty.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour

Bumpy Cake

In 1875, Fred Sanders Schmidt, using a borrowed barrel of sugar, opened his first chocolate shop on Woodward Avenue in Detroit, Michigan. He’d come from Chicago after his first store was destroyed in the Great Chicago Fire of 1871.

Sanders was very successful, opening more than 50 shops throughout the Midwest. One of his better-known products was hot fudge. Somewhere along the way, a “Devil’s Food Buttercream Cake” acquired a thick layer of fudge frosting over stripes of vanilla buttercream. Customers loved it, and started asking for “the cake with the bumps.” Hence Detroit Bumpy Cake was born. The company still receives online orders for it from far-flung Motor City expats today.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour

St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake

German bakers know very well the yeasted, sweet coffeecake called kuchen. Sometimes topped with fruit, sometimes with cream, there’s a long baking tradition behind these dense, tasty yeasted coffeecakes. A baker in St. Louis had a mishap during the 1920s, reversing the proportions of butter and flour in the topping for a batch of kuchen. The error wasn’t discovered until the cake was done proofing, but, it being the Depression, the bakery’s owner John Hoffman decided to bake the cakes anyway.

It turned out to be a very tasty mistake, and the cake sold so well it became a regular offering and a St. Louis staple. In the decades since, there have been convenience-food knockoffs based on cake mix and cream cheese, with flavor riffs and variations from chocolate to pumpkin to raspberry, but the buttery, custard-like top of the original remains unmatched.

regional desserts via@kingarthurflour


Oregon and Washington are blessed with an abundance of locally grown berries and fruit. For almost 30 years, the skilled bakers at Grand Central Bakery in Portland, Oregon, have been putting it to good use. They invented an oversized, fluffy biscuit and baked it with a pool of jam in the center. So simple, yet undeniably spectacular.

We’ve only scratched the surface of America’s landscape of regional desserts. All are held up as their area’s best, part of each place’s identity. If you want to experience the true flavor of a place, seek out their iconic sweets.

What are your favorite regional desserts? What hometown specialties do you long for when you’re away? Let us know in the comments below, so the rest of us can plan our travels. And look for more regional specialties in the Holiday 2017 issue of Sift, which has already sold out online but is still available at most major newsstands. Here’s to many epic forkfuls of discovery!

Susan Reid

Chef Susan Reid grew up in New Jersey, graduated from Bates College and the Culinary Institute of America, and is presently the Food Editor of Sift magazine. She does demos, appearances, and answers food (and baking) questions from all quarters.


  1. Linda Sepeda

    No shoo fly lie from Pennsylvania Dutch country? Another former resident of the area begs me to bake these lives of heaven.

  2. EsJayKay

    If you’ve never had Shoo-fly pie, you’re missing out! That’s just one of the hundreds of delicious treats my Grammy baked, but it’s my favorite Pennsylvania Dutch pastry.

  3. Rachael Best

    Junior’s Cheesecake in Brooklyn, New York. It is a New York classic. Folks from all over the world zoom right to Junior’s just to have a slice of heavenly goodness. They come in all flavors–strawberry, blueberry, mocha, etc. You won’t be disappointed.

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Rachael: you can’t go wrong with NY Cheesecake in my book! Thanks for the shout out! Susan

    2. Sarah

      There is NO cheesecake like Junior’s in Brooklyn! It is the Platonic form of NYC cheesecake. It is what cheesecake is meant to be. Cannot be beat!

    3. Brenda Becker

      Juniors is a tourist trap now, and the only cheesecake worth getting is plain; the strawberry featured huge, hard, underripe strawberries glued down with a rubbery layer of red glop. Even the plain cheesecake is easily duplicated using a good homemade recipe like Maida Heatter’s or Rose Levy Berenbaum’s. The really beloved NYC treat is the “black and white cookie,” even though most of them are pretty bad, too!

  4. Diane Hart

    Looking for a recipe for Clemson Pie… yes, that Clemson = ACC Champs 3rd year in a row! Been asking around but so far no luck. Anyone know of this?

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Sorry, Diane, nothing is coming up other than the new pizza place in town. But if you wanted to do something team appropriate, no reason you couldn’t do a riff on Key Lime with orange juice instead! Susan

  5. Philip Jones, Twain Harte, CA

    Susan – No way you missed including the Nanaimo Bar recipe; a British Columbia “must have”. It is already in the KA online recipe file – and is the best desert item one can find – even works for breakfast with a hot drink of any kind.

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Hi, Philip! The post was based on the article in Sift, and we had done Nanaimo bars in the magazine in a previous issue. One of the advantages of online life is we’re freed from the constraints of paper. Our Nanaimo recipe is here. Susan

  6. Emmie

    Loved the great read. But sorry you messed up on the “classic key lime pie”. As a 6th generation Conch (Name for native Key Westers) I can assure you we use only a real pastry pie crust never ! graham (Good Lord!) and the pie is always topped with a beautifully tanned meringue.

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Hi, Emmie. We’ll bow to your decades of family preference; I know the meringue is a staple for a lot of creamy Southern pies. I have had it with both styles of crust in Florida and elsewhere; I think the graham cracker crust is probably from food companies marketing a convenience angle. Susan

  7. Colleen_MI

    Love that you included our Detroit Bumpy Cake. They make a caramel version, too, but the chocolate is the best. Another local company, Stroh’s, makes a Bumpy Cake ice cream, too, with chunks of the cake and thick ribbons of that fudge!

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Uh, oh, Colleen, I am helpless in the face of chocolate and caramel. That may have been better for me not to know…. Susan

    1. Susan Reid, post author

      Hi, Shirlene. I’d love to hear what desserts Utah claims as its own. I know honey is big there, but can you tell me how you guys are making yummy things with it? Susan

  8. Patty Hsiu

    San Francisco has the Blum’s Bakery Coffee Crunch Cake. Blum’s is gone now but there are some bakeries that still make it. Eastern in Chinatown and Yasuchochi’s in Japantown come to mind. It’s a spectacular chiffon cake with coffee whipped cream frosting and light coffee toffee crunch crumbles all over.

  9. Tara

    Love it! My family is from southeast Kansas and I grew up enjoying “French waffle cookies” – a sort of take on pizzelles/galette cookies – they have a high sugar content that makes them almost caramelized when pressed in the iron. Crunchy and delicious! We eat them every Christmas.

  10. Kay

    Sanders Bumpy cake has always been the cake of choice for me for the last 50 years. There are a lot of other versions from other places including one called mile high bumpy cake. For Valentine’s day, the cake was in a heart shaped pan. That was the best!

    1. The Baker's Hotline

      Being a New England based company, Kathleen, a large portion of our recipes come from this region. From Anadama Bread, Boston Cream Pie, Nantucket Cranberry Cake, to Vermont Doughnut Holes, and yes, Grape Nut Pudding, our website and prior magazines definitely pay homage to our little corner of the country. We were thrilled to be able to do a bit of travelling and highlight desserts from other regions, not quite so close to home. We hope you give one of these recipes a try, maybe there’s a future favorite in there! Annabelle@KAF

  11. Nikki

    I know the recipes are on your website and they have been a subject in other blogs but…no mention of Whoopie Pies? the question is are they Maine or Pennsylvania? Probably start a friendly(?) argument there!
    No matter who claims them I wish they would travel a bit more to the west so we can enjoy them here in the Midwest

    1. The Baker's Hotline

      We can’t claim to take sides in the Whoopie Pie battle, Nikki! But we are definitely on the side of whoopie-pie lovers. We hope they make a migration out to the west sooner rather than later, but you should also feel empowered to make your own if a craving hits. Happy baking! Kye@KAF

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *